References
For applications for progression to a higher band applicants are required to provide the names, titles and contact details of two nominated referees.
Applicants should not nominate close colleagues, collaborators, co-authors or former students as referees, to ensure the references gathered provide an objective and unbiased assessment of their application. Applicants must declare any conflict of interest or areas of collaboration by indicating this when submitting their application. As a guide, co-authoring two or three publications with a referee would not normally be considered a conflict of interest. However, a more extensive publication record with a referee may indicate a close professional relationship and would be regarded as a conflict. Similarly, where any collaboration or co-authorship took place five or more years ago and there has been no substantial subsequent collaboration, this would not normally be considered a conflict of interest.
There may be circumstances in which exceptions to the above guidance may be appropriate, such as:
- In disciplines in which there are few academics, individuals with whom the applicant has collaborated on research may be nominated as referees. In such cases, the nature and extent of the collaboration should be declared, and the referee will be required to declare their interest when submitting a reference.
- In disciplines that typically have a lower publication expectation, co-authoring fewer than three publications may be considered a conflict of interest. Applicants should not nominate referees with whom they have co-authored the majority of their publications, regardless of their total number of publications.
Prior to nominating referees, the applicant must confirm with the referees that they are willing and able to provide a reference prior to providing their details.
Referees:
- are expected to be external to the University;
- In exceptional circumstances, where a referee is internal to the University, they must not be eligible for consideration under ACP (12) themselves.;
- should be of appropriately high academic standing and recognised authorities in their field; and
- must not have a direct academic association with the applicant (e.g. as a research collaborator or former student).
A referee’s input is critical in enabling a full and objective assessment of an applicant’s contribution. Referees are therefore requested to comment across the entire range of the applicant’s duties with explicit reference to the relevant Assessment Criteria and to provide a full and frank appraisal of the applicant’s suitability for progression.
Referees can provide useful insights into all aspects of the applicant’s work but are especially important in assessing both contribution and standing in the subject or discipline.
Referees’ reports are subject to the strictest confidentiality; however, referees will be made aware that in providing a reference, they give their explicit permission for the use of that reference for consideration under the ACP (12) scheme. Confidential references are normally exempt from disclosure under the terms of data protection legislation. Despite this, we often receive requests from applicants for copies of their references. By default, we will not disclose references without checking with the referee first.