Performance Descriptors (Bandings)
For each area of assessment, the committee will award one of the following performance descriptors:
- Outstanding Evidence*
- Strong Evidence**
- Moderate Evidence
- Insufficient/Unclear Evidence
- Clearly Unsatisfactory
The lowest two bandings (‘Clearly Unsatisfactory’ and ‘Insufficient/Unclear Evidence’) are deemed to be below the threshold for progression.
* A score in the Outstanding Evidence banding would be expected for applications which demonstrate the applicant has delivered exceptional accomplishments, demonstrated in their achievement of the Assessment Criteria.
**A score in the Strong Evidence banding would be expected for applications which demonstrate the applicant has exceeded expectations, demonstrated in their achievement of the Assessment Criteria.
Determination of suitable award levels
The committee should determine the outcome of an application based upon its assessment of the evidence compared against the Assessment Criteria. Where the committee feels there is evidence that an application should be awarded differently to what has been applied for (i.e. a Professor who applied within band demonstrating evidence that supports progression to a higher band, or vice versa), the committee may make the award they deem most suitable in relation to the evidence submitted.
The committee should ensure that clear justification exists for for all decisions made.
Professors in the first three points of band 1 (points 68, 69 and 70)
For applicants who the committee have assessed as meeting and maintaining the expected level of performance since being appointed/promoted to the level of (Teaching/Research) Professor at Grade 12, an award of one increment should be made.
For applicants who the committee have assessed as exceeding the expected level of performance since being appointed/promoted to the level of (Teaching/Research) Professor at Grade 12, the applications should be measured against the Assessment Criteria to determine the suitable level of award.
Higher band awards
Progression to a higher band would usually be to the bottom point of the new band, or two increments, whichever is the greater.
Where an application is assessed (against the criteria for the band being sought) as meeting at least the ‘Strong Evidence’ performance descriptor, the committee could opt to award three increments on the basis of exceptional performance. The committee should record a clear justification in these circumstances.
Within band applications
Where the committee believe that increments within an applicant’s current band are the most suitable award, the decision on the number of increments should be guided by the performance descriptors that have been agreed by the committee.
The maximum number of increments awarded for within band progression would normally be three in any given round of the scheme.